Walmart “A Who Knew Carol” Ad Review – Walton Goggins Joins the Muppets

Last year Walmart put Walton Goggins in a green fur suit and called him the Grinch. This year it has swapped one holiday grump for another and borrowed the most beloved version of him. “A Who Knew Carol” drops Goggins into a faithful re-staging of “Scrooge,” the opening number of 1992’s The Muppet Christmas Carol, with Kermit, Miss Piggy, Gonzo, Rizzo and friends singing about the meanest man in town. It is lavish, warm and genuinely well made. It is also a 2-minute-19-second music video in which the store is mostly a punchline.

WHAT HAPPENS ON SCREEN

A title card, “A New Carol Begins,” floats over snowy rooftops before the camera drops into a candlelit Victorian street packed with puppets, extras and a market stall piled high with red apples. A narrator welcomes us to “a whole new Christmas Carol” and Rizzo immediately breaks the spell to point out that there was no Walmart back then. It is the best joke in the film because it is the only one that admits what is going on.

Then the song kicks in. Townsfolk and Muppets take turns warning each other about Mr. Scrooge, a dark top-hatted silhouette who stalks through the crowd while everyone shrinks out of his way. We pass Miss Piggy, Kermit and Fozzie in front of a shop sign reading “Fozziwig Rubber Chickens,” Gonzo and Rizzo working the edges of the frame, a group of carolers around a candlelit tree, and Pepe the King Prawn cheerfully noting that he was not in the original either. A gift gag involving a lava lamp is explained to death on camera, which is a very Muppet way of letting a joke die.

The back half lands on the brand. A rewritten lyric about gifts nobody wants gives way to the campaign’s line, “Who knew?,” and the “A Who Knew Carol” title sign, lit up like a theater marquee with the Walmart wordmark on top. Scrooge finally gets his close-up in a dark doorway, candle in hand, answering every cheer with “Humbug.” The tag belongs to two glowing ghost versions of Statler and Waldorf, who promise three new ghosts “for legal reasons” and set up the rest of the season.

CREDITS

Brand: Walmart. Film: “Walmart Presents: A Who Knew Carol (Full Version),” 2:19, uploaded to Walmart’s official YouTube channel on October 26, 2026, made in collaboration with Disney and The Muppets Studio. Agency: Dept W and Pub W, Publicis Groupe’s dedicated Walmart teams bringing together Fallon, Leo New York, The Community, Digitas and Zenith. Production company: RadicalMedia. Director: Randall Einhorn (SARBY directed the social content). Edit: Union Editorial and Plural. Post: Harbor. Cast: Walton Goggins as Ebenezer Scrooge and Stephanie Beatriz as Scrooge’s niece, with Kermit the Frog, Miss Piggy, The Great Gonzo, Rizzo the Rat and Pepe the King Prawn. Credits per shots, Campaign US, Marketing Dive and Roastbrief.

THE EXECUTION

Randall Einhorn and RadicalMedia have done the hard part right. The sets are practical, the street is deep and busy, and the camera glides from puppet to puppet the way Brian Henson’s original did, so the whole thing feels like a lost reel from 1992 rather than a CGI pastiche. The lighting is all amber windows and blue snow, and the puppeteering in the background is as good as anything in the foreground.

The odd choice is Goggins. Walmart pays him to be the face of “Who Knew?,” and for most of the running time he is a cape and a hat seen from behind. The film keeps him in shadow to build up his reveal, which works musically, but it means the brand’s spokesman is the least present thing on screen. Michael Caine played it straight and let the Muppets be silly around him; Goggins barely gets to play it at all.

WHAT WORKS AND WHAT DOESN’T

What works: the respect for the source material. Fallon and the Publicis Walmart teams worked with Disney and The Muppets Studio on every detail, per Campaign US, and it shows. The meta jokes about Walmart not existing in Victorian London, newcomers who were not in the original, and ghosts renamed for legal reasons are all in the Muppets’ own voice. Statler and Waldorf as heckling spirits are a perfect fit, and the long-form cut gives the song room to breathe instead of chopping it into a 30-second sizzle reel.

What doesn’t: as an ad, the film is mostly a setup. The actual Walmart offer, gifts, Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals and Express Delivery in as little as 30 minutes, is pushed to the follow-up ghost spots. Here the store is a joke in the first 20 seconds and a sign in the last 40. The “Who Knew?” platform is supposed to surprise people with what Walmart sells, and nothing in this film surprises you about Walmart. It surprises you about how good a Muppet tribute can look on a retail budget.

VERDICT

“A Who Knew Carol” is the most charming holiday launch of the season so far, and it will be shared by everyone who still watches The Muppet Christmas Carol every December. But it borrows nearly all of its goodwill from a 34-year-old film, hides its own star and leaves the selling to the sequels. Gorgeous tribute, thin advertising. Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Exit mobile version