Most brand repositionings begin with a deck. Aer Lingus begins its new American push with a confession. According to the airline’s own research, two-thirds of Americans surveyed do not know what Aer Lingus is, and some guessed a pasta brand, a wrestling move or a type of dog. So instead of hiding the problem, “The Irish Airline” puts it on the table, literally, and hands it to Sharon Horgan. The 90-second film from Uncommon Creative Studio, directed by Rachel Stubbings through Merman and co-written by Horgan herself, is live on the official Aer Lingus YouTube channel and is running across US digital platforms.
A lunch meeting with a naming problem
The setup is a brand meeting disguised as a long lunch. Horgan arrives at a sunny, plant-filled restaurant where the Aer Lingus team is waiting, and a suited executive gushes that they are so glad to have her on board and that the American market will love it. Horgan asks the obvious question: do Americans know what Aer Lingus is? The pause that follows is the joke. Then the guesses tumble out around the table: a cologne, a Scandinavian furniture brand, “some kind of sex thing”, and from the hapless Shane, crypto, which gets shot down with “Not everything’s about crypto.”
Horgan’s diagnosis is blunt. Americans are direct, she says, they like it when the thing is called the thing that it does. She proves it with two quick props from neighbouring tables: what the Irish call a strimmer is a weed whacker, because it whacks weeds, and a dummy is a pacifier, because it pacifies your baby. Then she asks for a card, writes THE IRISH AIRLINE above the Aer Lingus logo, holds it up and lets the team mumble that they probably should have just called it that. “Well, we didn’t,” comes the reply, followed by the perfect Horgan button: “OK, should we talk money?” The end card simply reads Aer Lingus, The Irish Airline.
Why it works
The smartest thing here is honesty about a real business problem. Airlines usually advertise lie-flat seats, smiling crew and sunsets over a wing. Uncommon skipped all of that and went straight for the reason the brand is invisible in the US: the name does not tell you what it is. Turning that weakness into the joke, and then into a descriptor that will sit under the logo for years, is a proper brand idea rather than a one-off sketch. It is the same instinct behind the best challenger campaigns: say the awkward thing first and the audience trusts you with the rest.
Horgan is also exactly the right messenger. American viewers know her from “Catastrophe” and “Bad Sisters”, she is unmistakably Irish without being a postcard, and her dry, slightly impatient delivery makes the brand look like it can laugh at itself. Because she co-wrote it and the film came out of her own production company, the dialogue sounds like her and not like a copywriter’s idea of her. The strimmer and pacifier gags are small, but they explain the strategy in plain language.
Where it falls short
The problem is the length. Ninety seconds of people talking at a restaurant table is a lot to ask from a digital audience that has never heard of you, and the middle sags. The naming guesses and the two translation gags make the same point twice, and the film only really snaps back into life when Horgan grabs the card.
There is also almost no airline in this airline ad. No plane, no cabin, no Dublin, no mention in the film of the things the press release wants Americans to know, such as US preclearance at Dublin or the European network. That is a deliberate choice for a first brand chapter, and the end line covers the basics, but it puts a lot of pressure on future executions to turn a good name joke into reasons to book. And the “sex thing” line, while it gets the biggest laugh, is the kind of gag that will travel faster than the brand name attached to it.
Craft and credits
Stubbings keeps the direction invisible in the best way: tight singles, quick reaction shots, and enough room for the awkward silences to land. Linda Wu’s photography gives the room a warm, expensive glow that reads more lifestyle than sitcom, and the edit by Saam Hodivala at Shift Post is at its sharpest in the reaction cutaways. Credits listed on LBB include ECD Julie Matheney, creatives Duncan Clark and Laura Hutchinson, agency producer Anthony Borkett, Merman executive producers Siobhan Murphy and Spencer Dodd, producer Alicia Farren, production designer Damien Creagh, post and VFX by Electric Theatre Collective with colourist Luke Morrison, and sound by 750mph. Media is handled by MG OMD.
Verdict
“The Irish Airline” is a clear, self-aware piece of brand fixing that knows exactly what problem it is solving and has the perfect person to solve it. It is funny in a dry, grown-up way and leaves behind a descriptor that will outlive the ad. It is also a little long, a little static and light on reasons to fly. A smart first chapter that needs a sharper second one.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5